Historical Memory Of The Memorial - 1525 Words

Since the opening of the Emancipation Memorial in 1876, there has always been controversy regarding the accuracy of the message that the monument provides to its viewers. The Emancipation Memorial has become an example of the criticisms that many warped monuments face today, such as heroification. In order to have an effective monument, Loewen believes that the monument needs to be honest in the story that it shows, which includes not omitting any important figures, no racism, and no glorification and heroification of figures or ideas in the monument. Many have agreed that the image depicted in the Memorial is deceiving and creates a misleading historical memory for tourists. Historical memory is the way in which an event is remembered, influenced by monuments, books, movies, and other forms of propaganda. This is significant because the historical memory of the Emancipation Memorial has had a large impact on the group of Americans who have seen the Memorial as a validation for their thoughts that Lincoln was the sole figure who freed blacks from the awful chains of slavery. The degree to which the Emancipation Memorial needs to be toppled is extremely urgent. The monument should be toppled because of the degree of historical inaccuracy that the monument depicts onto the viewer’s historical memory. The Emancipation Memorial should be toppled because it distorts the historical memory of the emancipation of the slaves by heroifying Lincoln, which is one of Loewen’s criteriaShow MoreRelatedThe Monuments And Museums : Art1164 Words   |  5 Pagesthe displays from the Jewish Museum Berlin, The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, the Micha Ullman s Bibliothek Memorial, Memorial De La Shoah Paris and the counter-monument Monument against Fascism Hamberg. The assignment will give a brief introduction to the Shoah. It will question and discuss what impact the experience has on visitors to the museums and monuments, would it better the understanding of the historical narrative and is it necessary to view such atrocity in order to pay tributeRead MoreThe Holocaust Museum : The Importance Of Monuments1079 Words   |  5 Pagesthey should take into consideration. Including; the location, the cost, historical background, nature, and the significance of the monument, as well as the community’s perception about the monument. Controversy grew when non-Jewish and Jewish citizens heard they were going to build a Holocaust museum in The National Mall in Washington, D.C. (. Musser). This angered many people due to the fact that a museum dedicated to the memory of the Holocaust would be built in the United States, who did littleRead MoreThe Battle Of The Confederate War1390 Words   |  6 Pagesthe issue further, arguing that all Confederate Civil War memorials should be removed. I disagree; the Confederate monuments hold too great a historical value to simply dispose of them like last night’s dinner. The monuments and memorials under fire all possess similar traits that causes social and racial tension. By first identifying these traits we can then make the necessary adjustments to remedy the issue. Again, Confederate war memorials possess a valuable glimpse into the past and are worth preservingRead MoreGerman History Essay1730 Words   |  7 Pagesvaluable to acknowledge history, whether it be thro ugh documentation, education, or architectural preservation. However, history can be complex and ugly, stained by war, genocide, and destruction. Therein lies a philosophical controversy: should these historical â€Å"stains† be acknowledged or buried? What role do these ugly histories have in the development of a society? Within the last century, no nation has been forced to confront these questions on the same scale that Germany has (Levinger 118). With aRead MorePreserving Memory : The Struggle For Creating America s Holocaust Museum871 Words   |  4 PagesPreserving Memory: The Struggle to Create America’s Holocaust Museum was written by Edward T. Linenthal. This book was published by the Columbia University Press in New York. The book was copyrighted in 1995 and then once again in 2001. This book also has 336 pages. Preserving Memory: The Struggle to Create America’s Holocaust Museum gives the reader an extensive overview in the development of the Holocaust Memorial Museum that is located in Washington D.C. In this edition of the book, LinenthalRead MoreAn Anti Climax1500 Words   |  6 Pageshighlighted individual sacrifice and honor.† You seem to take this point for granted. It is the focal point for your research rather than a claim that needs to be investigated through careful historical analysis. In future work, you need to pay close attention to the rhetoric and actions of the various historical actors and try to understand how they are using these repatriations and identifications to do specific social and political work (which may or may not align to your current claim that theyRead MoreAnalysis Of The Submission By Amy Waldman913 Words   |  4 Pagescan be a way to preserve important traumatic memories for future generations to remember and learn from. Ellie Wiesel write s, â€Å"...I needed to give some meaning to my survival...I only know that without this testimony, my life as a writer—or my life, period—would not have become what it is: that of a witness who believes he has a moral obligation to try to prevent the enemy from enjoying one last victory by allowing his crimes to be erased from human memory† (Wiesel viii). Although Wiesel s Night isRead MoreFacing It By Yusef Komunyakaa1158 Words   |  5 PagesIt†, by the poet Yusef Komunyakaa, he himself is the one who is speaking, the poem is about his own life experience at the Vietnam Memorial. The way a person can tell if the own poet of the poem is the speaker is by the use of first person. In this case, the poet uses words like â€Å"I† and â€Å"I’m† that support the fact that he is the speaker. The Vietnam War was a Historical event taken place in Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia. Which was one of the first War that African Americans were integra ted with WhiteRead MoreWhy Monuments Should Be Treated With Utmost Respect?1192 Words   |  5 Pagesmany different ways to memorialize a person or an event. Such as having a day to remember the person the monument was built for and having a monument built in memory of the people who actually deserve them. Most monuments should be treated with the utmost respect because of their meaning. They can also be placed on a sacred site or a historical landmark for a specific reason. When creating a monument you really have to think about the present and the future of the monument. Even though monuments canRead MoreWhy Monuments Should Be Treated With Utmost Respect?1192 Words   |  5 Pagesmany different ways to memorialize a person or an event. Such as having a day to remember the person the monument was built for and having a monument built in memory of the people who actually deserve them. Most monuments should be treated with the utmost respect because of their meaning. They can also be placed on a sacred site or a historical landmark for a specific reason. When creating a monument you really have to think about the present and the future of the monument. Even though monuments can